The answer to this question is answered pretty simply – both these guns are Glocks, and so they are really reliable. The maintenance and cleaning of the weapon must be possible without tools. Other than that, the Glock 21 is superior to the Glock 19. This is because cleanliness and care are not always possible. I read many, many gun articles about short barrel handguns, both revolver and semi-auto. Glock 17 vs. Glock 19: The Devil is in the Details, Glock Specs Comparison Chart: G17 vs. G19, A Larger Gun is More Impressive (or Is It? One of the most critical aspects of a handgun is its accuracy. I also have built Govt/1911 pistols that competed on the National level in IpSC, with my favorite match pistol digesting an estimated 30,000 rds of .45 ACP, with no major problems. After the first 15,000 shots of standard ammunition, the weapon must be inspected for wear. I opted to stick with the Glock rail and the non-ambi mag release. In all reality, firearms are mechanical devices and like any mechanical device, they can and do fail. In 1980, the Austrian army announced that it is looking for a new handgun to replace their Walther P38 dating from the Second World War. Model: G17 Gen4. Model . Has anyone shot both who could tell me any difference you’ve noticed? After all, the world of armed confrontation is above all armies of the world. No, he qualified his decision the 19 is better based on certain criteria. Of course, if concealed carry is not an issue for you, or you simply prefer the feel of  the larger Glock 17, you are free to disagree. I carry a Glock 22 about 25% of the time and would have no problem carrying the Glock 17 which is the same only in 9MM. For this reason, I regard this category also as a draw. After trying many many different pistols, My personal favorite is the G19, Gen 3. Even though this weapon is undoubtedly relevant and offers a range of impressive roles, if tomorrow the world as we know it ceased to exist, it is the G19 that we would secure first as, in our opinion, to be able to evolve discreetly is something that can not be replaced. Both take 9mm cartridges, both are made from the same high-quality mix of steel and polymer, and both of them ar… Well, in truth the best one for you will depend on a variety of factors. The reason for this is because a gun’s mechanical accuracy is generally less of a factor than how experienced you are using it. But that’s ok, so does everybody else. This trait is shared with its stablemate the G20. BTDT. So I accompanied him to the range to see what was going on. The G19X comes in a standard Glock box, but in a different desert tan color, which according to Glock is called the Coyote. Size Comparison: G lock 17 vs Glock 19 . Top 8 Best Thermal Scopes On The Market 2020 Reviews & Buying Guide, Best Aimpoint for AR15 On The Market 2020 Reviews, 8 Best Tactical Shotguns for Home Defense in 2020 – Ultimate Reviews & Buyer’s Guide, Best Handgun for Beginners & Home Defense in 2020 Reviews, Top 5 Best .380 Pistols For Concealed Carry in 2020 – The Real Manstoppers, Taurus Judge .410 Revolver Review [Updated 2020], Benjamin Marauder Pellet Pistol – In-Depth Review, Review Of Top 5 Best Pistols For 3 Gun Competition [2020]. In addition, when using extended length magazines in the shorter grips of the G26 and G19, the magazines may not be supported adequately, so failures to feed are more likely. Even though the Glock 17 is the weapon that triggered the avalanche of Glocks, this model has some disadvantages in an organization that wants to be all-encompassing. But – and it is a big but – the Glock 19, being a little smaller, is simply better for concealed carry, and for this reason it is my preferred gun. Even with my disabilities, I found the Glocks easier to shoot than the 1911 platform. Many will say that the most versatile and most necessary firearm in terms of survival remains the 12 gauge shotgun. The Glock 19 is when you make the Glock 17 compact. The gripping ability and size are much reduced in Glock 19 as compared to Glock 17. Simpker = better? Where you carry it, and what kind of holster you use, can make all the difference. I group better when precision shooting with the Glock 17. Its overall … Well, maybe. It’s for this reason that making a direct comparison of the technical accuracy of both pistols is somewhat useless. No more than 20 defective operations are allowed during the first 10,000 shots, not even the simplest failures. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites. The Glock 17 and the Glock 19 are, essentially, the same gun, except that the Glock 19 has a slightly smaller barrel and grip. S&W Airweight Review – Does It Worth Money? Again, terms of cost, both weapons are fairly similar. Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. I have the 17c Gen 4. This is worse if the extended magazine touches something during firing, like a barricade or window frame. The 19 model, on the other hand, has a shorter barrel at just 4 inches. It threw 180 gr hard cast lead .45 Bullets out at 1400 fps, and 230 gr JFP at 1200 fps. welcome to usa online shopping center. Once either of the guns are loaded (condition 1), the only concern for the user is to aim and press the trigger. The manufacturer is required to provide the Ministry of Defense with a complete set of drawings and diagrams. I talked one of my friends into buying a G23, which is a great little pistol. Both weapons continue to develop, with the most recent models being the Gen 4 series. In tests, though, this turns out not to be the case. Though my preference is for the 19, I have no doubt that the long and passionate stand-off between these two guns will continue for quite some time. Information: I spent over a decade as a competitor in IpSC, and also as a licensed gunsmith specialising in building PRACTICAL pistols. I started experimenting with the Glocks. And when I test fired it, it was totally reliable. Untrue…the gun is as accurate as the shooter is trained. In the sum total of all shots fired, the Sig bested the Glock by malfunctioning 27 times, whereas the Glock malfunctioned 30 times. And honestly, if you are worried about half an inch, your insecurities are not going to be reduced by a Glock 17. Ordering parts after troubleshooting your VP9 is quite the hassle, to say the least. When we consider the purchase of a firearm from the point of view of survivalism, one of the first considerations should be the robustness of the tool. suitable for both beginner and experienced shooters, Disclaimer Policy And FTC Affiliate Disclosure |. This current comparison is much ado about nothing but preference…go to a range and shoot both and select…who knows, you may not like a Glock at all. Of course, some people simply prefer the feel of a larger gun. The guns feel essentially the same, although the Model 19 has a slightly shorter grip. Glock 17 has a larger barrel of 114mm. I can remember back to the early 1990s when I got my Glock 19 (2nd generation at the time) and my Glock 17 (used first generation variant). The only firearm I have ever used that has never failed to function is my Smith & Wesson 586 revovler. There are conflicting views on this point because advocates of the 19 maintain that it is more about the person using the weapon than the small difference between the sights. Official Url . your choice of clothing can really effect concealment. The durability of a Glock is the subject of increasingly extreme tests on Youtube, for example. The Austrian engineer, Gaston Glock, having no experience with the world of weaponry. This was especially noticeable during long strings, at multiple targets. When we talk about the difference between calibers, we rely primarily on military testimony. I use for concealed carry and am very happy with the gun overall. Given the popularity of the two pistols, a lot of people debate the issue of Glock 17 vs Glock 19 for concealed carry or just as an addition to the gun safe. For outdoors excursions in Grizzly bear territory, I carried a Stainless Steel RANDALL Govt in .45 SUPER, with a 6″ ramped and coned barrel. Some Specifics about the Glock 17 vs. Glock 19, Top 10 Cheap Handguns for Sale in 2020 Right Now. I had a 21; bought a 21SF to replace it because it fits my hand better. August 2000, brand new Glock 17s, tested by my agency, had multiple failure to feed issues (aka: jams). Yes your assumption is correct, lasers and/or flashlights can be attached to both models. Simple, reliable, robust, and regardless of the model chosen, the Glock is undoubtedly a handgun that deserves special attention for the survivalist. Are they generally more reliable than some other make/model firearms, it is possible. Looking for to buy Glock 26 or Glock 19 in 2020. For this reason, I’m tempted to suggest that the people who feel a difference between the two guns in this regard are simply imagining it. The G19 is a G17 that fits perfectly with all the criteria of the survivalist. BAD BEARS BEWARE. If you need 17 rounds (or 5, for that matter) to disable an attacker, you need to spend some more time on the range. Thank you Ken, what do you sell the 17 & 19 for. Both the Glock 17 and 19 are truly outstanding guns, making use of the latest materials and a design which is simple and reliable. Glock 21 vs Glock 19 - hand size and grip control My hands are below average size for a male, newbie in patrol. The G17 is all yours for the taking. Let’s get some basics out of the way, for those of you who are new to this debate. If you are lucky enough to live in a hot climate, where thin shirts are commonplace, pistol grips are typically more at risk of printing than barrels, and for this reason the Glock 19 is preferable in these situations. I found the G34, with the longer sight radius, significantly more accurate at longer ranges, but also significantly slower at close range quick and dirty stages. I’m sure it is possible, through a series of handler errors, to make them seize up, but for most people most of the time both guns are as reliable as it gets. I had to shift my grip during the draw, and for long strings. During normal use, under no circumstances can the user can be in danger due to the ejection of a socket. I personally am not in a situation where I could legally concele carry a handgun (living in California). The slightly larger ammunition capacity of the Glock 17 means that you get an extra two rounds. These differences will affect which you prefer, but only if you are particularly large or small. But if you love the “big and bold,” then, why not? This makes what he came up with truly outstanding achievement – the Glock 17 was quickly adopted by shooters all over Europe, and even received a NATO stock number. Neither is better. The Gen 3 Glock 17 and Gen 3 Glock 19 both cost $499.00 where the Gen4 Glock 17 and Gen4 Glock 19 both cost $547.00. The GLOCK 19 is billed as being better for people with smaller hands, but only marginally so; the trigger reach (the distance from the back of the pistol grip to the front face of the trigger) is only 0.03 inches longer on the GLOCK 17 vs GLOCK 19.

Please include attribution to with this graphic.

What makes this question even more interesting is that the Glock 17 and Glock 19 cost exactly the same price. For maximum reliability with 9MM, I swapped in .9mm extractors, ejectors, and magazines, but experimenting with .40 slides combined with an after market 9mm conversipn barrel, no other changes, proved quite reliable. For a fun summary of everything in this article, check out the infographic below (and see our “winner”).


I imagine these are the same people who, in that situation, will fire off their whole magazine in two seconds, and maybe hit once. Both guns are great! Weapons with scores of less than 70% of the total possible points will not be considered for military use. For most of us, though the difference in size can be felt, neither gun is too big or too small. Both of these guns can be concealed well. At the range, which of the two do you find to be most accurate? The survivalist’s handgun must not only be extremely reliable, robust, and efficient. The Glock is the AK47 of the handgun, and it continues to prove its durability under conditions where most other semi-auto would become unusable. The construction of the weapon must not exceed 58 individual pieces (the equivalent of a P38). The question you proposed was “which is better”. In addition, your choice of clothing can really effect concealment.eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'gunnewsdaily_com-box-4','ezslot_2',113,'0','0'])); For these reasons, I’m not going to say that the Glock 19 is a perfect concealed carry pistol. I gave up serious pistol competition, but still enjoyed delusions of being capable of protecting myself with a pistol, if necessary, from man or beast. As soon as I corrected his grip, the pistol became trouble free. RE: RELIABILITY? !Glock Pistol Spec. Measurement and testing tools must not be necessary for the long-term maintenance of the weapon. As a former IpSC competitor, I spent over a decade competing with truly PRACTICAL pistols. A PROPERLY built 1911/Govt type pistol can be as reliable as any other mechanical object. The half-inch that has been shaved off the Glock 19’s grip makes carrying it concealed a lot easier than that number, on paper, would indicate. Your email address will not be published. However, in my opinion this two-round difference means very little for practical purposes. During that time, with experience on around 300 1911/Govt pistols, and many tens of thousands of .45 ACP loads fired, I have LITERALLY seen EVERY SINGLE PART of a 1911 pistol break or fall off. Accurate and flat shooting out to 100 yds. As I watched from the left side, it was obvious that his larger hands and thumb position were the cause of the problems. Why choose? The difference in size also extends to the trigger mechanism, with the 19’s being a little more tight that the larger 17’s. It is simply THE BEST … FOR ME. In truth, though, this will make very little difference unless you are shooting in competition, and also adds some weight to the gun. The well documented reliability issues of the transition perior Gen4 Glocks are testimony to these engineers mantras; No mechanical object is “perfectly reliable”. With the weapon, we also have two chargers, an operation manual, and a brush to clean it. YPMMV. Chargers should not need any assistance to reload the weapon. I want to know which is better. The size of the Glock 17 is, in our humble opinion, the only parameter that prevents this weapon from being a suitable solution when it comes to the sphere of personal defense. The glock rail because, as mentioned, it fits my old holsters and I don't see an advantage of the larger PIC rail anyway. That’s not to over-simplify the issue. The debate of the caliber is we’re afraid to say, endless. The Glocks (17 and 19) were thrown off a plane, dragged behind a car for miles, immersed in mud for months, etc. All constituent parts must be interchangeable between weapons.

Macaroni Pasta Lidl, Coconut Processing Technology, Gsauca Round 2, What Does An Architect Do, How To Keep Hair From Getting Frizzy At The Beach, Side Effects Of African Star Apple, Switzerland Points Of Interest, Uss Gerald Ford Latest News, Shelter Wood Furnace 2626,